Wednesday, November 27, 2013

The Scarlet Letter: The Rest a.k.a. In Conclusion, I'm Not Impressed.

Covering chapters ten to about twenty here, and I know that seems slightly excessive, but bear with me here. First off, let's get something straight here: this story ended up being pretty lame as a whole. Yeah, it has a definite beginning and end, some absolutely delightful prose, and some pretty lengthy threats of eternal damnation like every self-respecting piece of Puritan literature ought to possess, but those are pretty much its only redeeming facets.
The story is predictable by about chapter twelve. Dimmesdale is the father. Chillingworth got close to him with the hopes of exacting some peculiar revenge scheme. Pearl is confused. Hester is on the same level as Pearl literally and figuratively. It could've been a short story - or a horrible soap opera written in a play format.
Forget what I said about this covering to chapter twenty, I'm going to go ahead and rant about the whole rest of the book. Like, seriously. I actually liked Hester until the end when she agrees to Dimmesdale's plea that the three of them run off somewhere. She automatically agrees, and that made me so unbelievably angry because that crooked preacher was a total tool! (And some other things I thought better of typing aloud.) He lets Hester spend seven years being tormented by the townspeople. She's publicly humiliated, jailed, shoved out of town and forced to wear an eternal reminder of her indiscretion that puts her at odds with her daughter repeatedly throughout the story.
All Dimmesdale does is angst about it so dramatically that he drops dead.
It makes me angry because Hester's life literally turned to shambles because of their actions. However, she still protected him through everything and never gave away his identity. Even when it caused a strain in her relationship with Pearl, she wouldn't tell. Dimmesdale is so worried about his precious morals and reputation that he chooses to run away from it all rather than stand and face the controversy like Hester had to. It makes me mad because I consider it another example of how not even gender, but being a female is so frowned upon in this story and in this society.
I'm not really sure how I wanted to the story to end, but I do know that I wish Hester had some more character development like Pearl did. Her dying a creaky old adulteress seems wrong to me. Maybe if Hester had something to say to Dimmesdale that didn't pretty much translate to her fawning all over him when they met in the woods, I would have been pleased. (Not likely.) I'm literally seething over this. People say Twilight destroyed women's power, but if you ask me this book really isn't any better.
I guess a good thing that I took from reading this book was that the person in charge of making the story more modern for Easy A missed a few key points. Not that I'm complaining.
So basically, what I learned in boating school from this book is that Puritans were total sexist losers.

5 comments:

  1. I. Could not. Agree. More. There was not ONE thing you said that I could disagree with. I'm honestly just glad to find someone who shares my frustrations with Hester willfully bearing all of these burdens on her own. She constantly reminds me of Bella from Twilight as her actions and ideas seem to stem from strength and courage, only to come across as stupidity.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice ranting about the book Sam! Well I agree with you that the book wasn't amazing, but I didn't hate it as much as you did. I found it kind of nice that she chose to run away with him. She had so much hate at first in this town, and her and the minister finally made peace with each other. She loved him, so this part of the book really did not bother me to much.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Interesting response. I wasn't impress or taken away by it either.I second vickie's comment about Hester running away with him although I would replace the word nice and say it made sense. It fit the plot that the previous chapters and Hester's attitude towards the social environment she was living in.

    I don't think this book or twilight destroyed "women's power". It's bad/cliche story telling at worse since most of the characters lack depth(not just hester or whatver her face in twilight).

    ReplyDelete
  4. Samantha, you have some good comments that cover a large part of the literature, but I wish you had taken the time to go into a little more depth with some of your ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  5. LITERALLY THE BEST BLOG I HAVE EVER READ. I couldn't agree more with everything you said. I feel like I missed so many key points in the book and details because I was so completely detached while reading it. I feel like Hester's personality and character in the beginning of the book was so much more interesting than it was by the end. I'm not sure how Twilight translates to Hester and sexism because I always found Bella to be a strong willed person.

    ReplyDelete